News
Legal Insights: Parental Alienation in Ontario Family Law
How Ontario Courts Handle Parental Alienation: Key Cases and Lessons for Parents
Introduction
Parental alienation is a significant issue in family law, occurring when one parent manipulates a child into rejecting the other parent. Ontario courts recognize the damaging effects of alienation and have increasingly taken decisive action to protect children’s well-being.
In this Legal Insights article, we examine three important cases—A.M. v. C.H. (2019 ONCA 764), Y.H.P. v. J.N. (2023 ONSC 5766), and Kudrocova v. Kronberger (2023 ONCA 26)—and discuss how they shape the legal landscape for custody disputes involving parental alienation.
A.M. v. C.H. (2019 ONCA 764): A Clear Message from the Court
What Happened?
In this case, the mother systematically alienated the child from the father by making false allegations and restricting access. After years of strained relations, the father sought a custody transfer to repair the damage.
The Ontario Court of Appeal upheld the trial judge’s bold decision to transfer custody of the 14-year-old child from the mother to the father. The court also:
Ordered a no-contact period between the child and the mother. Mandated therapy to repair the father-child relationship. Stressed that removing an alienating parent’s custody may be necessary when alienation is severe.
Why It Matters
This case sent a strong message—when one parent actively alienates a child, the courts will intervene decisively, even if it means an abrupt change in the child’s living arrangements.
Y.H.P. v. J.N. (2023 ONSC 5766): The Importance of Early Intervention
What Happened?
Similar to A.M. v. C.H., this case involved a mother engaging in long-term alienation, falsely accusing the father of abuse and sabotaging therapy sessions. The court responded by: Ordering a four-month no-contact period between the mother and child. Awarding the father temporary exclusive custody. Mandating reunification therapy.
Why It Matters
This case reinforces the principles of A.M. v. C.H., showing that Ontario courts are increasingly willing to order strict remedies when alienation is identified. It also highlights the importance of early legal intervention—the sooner alienation is addressed, the greater the chance of reversing its effects.
Kudrocova v. Kronberger (2023 ONCA 26): A Different Approach to Parental Alienation
What Happened?
Unlike the previous cases, both parents engaged in alienation. The court had to decide whether to uproot the children from their respective parents or maintain the status quo. Given the high-conflict nature of the case, the Ontario Court of Appeal ruled that: Each twin would continue living with their respective parent. Therapeutic interventions had failed, so further forced custody changes might not be in the children’s best interests. The court must balance the need to correct alienation with the immediate welfare of the child.
Why It Matters
This case shows that not all instances of parental alienation lead to immediate custody transfers. Courts will consider: How long the alienation has been occurring. The child’s stability in their current home. Whether therapy and interventions have been effective.
While courts will intervene to stop alienation, they also recognize that forced changes are not always the best solution.
Key Takeaways for Parents Facing Parental Alienation
Based on these cases, here’s what parents involved in alienation disputes should know:
The Courts Will Act – If alienation is severe, Ontario courts are willing to transfer custody to the targeted parent. Therapy Is Often Required – Courts prioritize reunification therapy before making permanent custody decisions. Time Matters – The longer alienation continues, the harder it is to undo, so seeking legal help early is critical. Every Case Is Unique – Courts balance correcting alienation with protecting the child’s current well-being, so outcomes vary.
Need Legal Help with Parental Alienation?
If you are dealing with parental alienation, a high-conflict custody battle, or a co-parenting dispute, legal action may be necessary to protect your relationship with your child.
At Martel Law Office, we understand the complexity of these cases and are here to provide strategic, results-driven legal representation.
Contact us today to discuss your case:
Martel Law Office Phone: 613-688-2938
Email: contact@martel-law.com
Let’s work together to protect your parental rights.